New York Daily News: High housing prices badly hurt New York

By: Dennis C. Vacco

Everyday goods in New York are becoming more expensive — and that includes housing.

This fall saw the most homes put up for sale in New York City in four years as sellers raced to take advantage of sky-high prices and tight inventory.

Some of this is simply New York being New York. People flock from all over the world to live here, which drives up housing demand to a seller’s delight.

But some of it is purely self-inflicted.

New York’s housing woes are chiefly due to a lack of supply. Our state ranks dead last — that’s 51st out of 50 states plus the District of Columbia — when it comes to home construction and affordability, according to Realtor.com.

How did this happen? Start with New York City’s zoning code, which was last updated in 1961. Back then, urban planners were worried about overcrowding, and so the code makes it difficult to build multi-family housing units.

If buyers are to reclaim any power in the housing market, the city needs to start by zoning for more multi-family apartment buildings.

New York’s building codes are likewise a problem. More than any other city, New York loves to dictate down to the nail what kinds of materials can be used in new homes, ruling out affordable alternatives and driving up costs. The same problem exists upstate in Buffalo where one developer maintains that it costs nearly $1 million per apartment to construct 300 affordable units.

New York also has some of the highest organized labor costs in the country, with union rates of $75 to $150 per hour plus benefits. Additionally, the mandates of the outdated Scaffold Law drive up insurance costs for developers.

New York’s approach to housing is clearly in urgent need of an overhaul. And there are even more headwinds on the way.

The first comes from corporate America. Compass, the largest real estate brokerage in America, has begun setting aside more listings into a kind of “luxury lane” rather than sending them immediately to Zillow and Redfin. These homes are only visible to exclusive members. Compass is even offering incentives to real estate agents to remove homes from StreetEasy, where many New Yorkers shop for housing.

A small handful of homes have always been privately listed, but Compass is trying to turn this into a profitable business model. Even fewer properties publicly listed will mean an even more strangled housing supply and even higher prices.

The second housing headwind comes from Mayor Mamdani’s freeze on rent rates, which took effect this autumn and impacts about a quarter of the city’s housing stock. This will harm landlords because they can’t recoup the rising costs of insurance, maintenance, and other expenses.

Is it any surprise that those landlords might try to offload their properties as the freeze takes effect? Rent regulation is generally considered one of the biggest deterrents to new housing construction.

We need to empower New York buyers and make New York an affordable place to live again. That means serious reforms that will bring our housing policy into the 21st century and make sure more homes can be built quickly.

If elected leaders seriously want to tackle the affordability crisis, housing is a great place to start.

Vacco is a partner with Lippes Mathias. He was the elected New York State attorney general from 1995-99 and had previously been appointed U.S. attorney for the Western District of New York by President Ronald Reagan.

Next
Next

Policy Pro: Scaffold law reform picks up steam, catching up with DOB chief